
November 19, 2026
In the course of labour negotiations, BCGEU and Vancity signed a letter of agreement under which both parties committed to take all reasonable steps to design a jointly sponsored DB plan for unionized and non-unionized employees by September 1, 2021. After the deadline for designing the plan passed, Vancity advised BCGEU that it no longer considered itself bound by the terms of the agreement and stated that it intended to proceed with a single employer DB plan for its non-union employees. BCGEU alleged the dialogue between the parties carried on past the deadline for completion of the plan’s design, which Vancity disputed. BCGEU subsequently commenced an action alleging breach of the agreement and fraudulent misrepresentation in connection with Vancity’s stated commitment to establishing the jointly sponsored DB plan.
BCGEU later sought to amend its claim to add a claim for specific performance to require Vancity to fulfil its alleged obligation to establish the jointly sponsored DB plan. The Supreme Court of British Columbia refused the amendment, finding that BCGEU had already treated the agreement as terminated and elected to seek damages, and that allowing the amendment would prejudice Vancity.
The British Columbia Court of Appeal allowed BCGEU’s appeal and permitted the amendment. In reaching its decision, the Court of Appeal considered whether allowing the amendment would be “just and convenient” and, reading the pleadings “generously” despite drafting deficiencies, concluded that they did not preclude BCGEU from adding a plea for specific performance. In particular, the Court of Appeal found that:
The Court of Appeal therefore allowed BCGEU to amend its pleadings to seek specific performance. The decision does not determine whether Vancity must establish the jointly sponsored DB plan, but it allows BCGEU to pursue specific performance as the underlying dispute continues.
Click on ‘More information’ below to read the decision: