Court Upholds Finding That Employer Contributions Had Not Vested
Authors:
November 17, 2026
The Saskatchewan Court of King’s Bench has upheld an arbitrator’s decision that locked-out employees were not entitled to their employer’s unvested savings plan contributions.
Unifor Canada, Local 594 (“Unifor”) members participated in a savings plan set out in a letter of understanding (“LOU”) that formed part of their collective agreement with Consumers’ Co-operative Refineries Limited (“CCRL”).CCRL matched employee contributions of up to 6.5% of pay. CCRL’s contributions vested after the calendar year in which they were made plus one additional year, meaning that the contributions made in 2018 would have vested on January 1, 2020.
The collective agreement ended on December 5, 2019, when a strike notice took effect and CCRL locked out employees. CCRL then refused to pay its 2018 contributions to members who had applied to withdraw their funds. Its position was that the contributions had not vested.
Unifor filed a grievance seeking payment of the 2018 employer contributions. The arbitrator dismissed the grievance, finding that although the matching contributions had been made, they were not scheduled to vest until after the collective agreement ended.
On judicial review, the Saskatchewan Court of King’s Bench found that the decision of the arbitrator was reasonable and dismissed the judicial review with costs. The Court held that whether a benefit has vested depends on the terms of the agreement that creates it. Under the LOU, members were not unconditionally entitled to the 2018 employer contributions before the collective agreement ended, so the contributions were not payable.
Click on ‘More information’ below to read the decision: